Social Work’s professional space in Scotland

I have to admit that the idea for this blog entry has been around for some time. For various reasons I have avoided writing it but after a brief Twitter discussion on Sunday I though it best to put some thoughts down.

The idea of professional space has interested me for some time. Andrew Cooper’s paper, The State of Mind We Are In was the first that I read that made me think about the idea. This blog entry will in no way offer what Cooper’s paper offered but will give some insight into my thinking abut this issue.

So what am I defining “professional space” as? Well for me it is a mixture of the professional identities, the social policies that are around and the prevailing economic or social conditions that people are exposed to. For the purposes of this entry I will use my own experiences of working in Social Work in Scotland for the last twenty years.

In Scotland one of the major changes has been regional re-organisation and the move to smaller unitary authorities. I started my career in Strathclyde Regional Council which was a large organisation that covered much of Scotland. It was Labour controlled and when I joined it (around 1990) had not enjoyed a good relationship with the Conservative government. To say the least there were a number of areas of conflict. Not least a strange electoral arrangement that meant the Conservative government did not need significant support in Scotland in order to be re-elected.

So there was a large governmental organisation here that seemed opposed to central government. SRC had a strong social and moral conscience (at least it felt it did to me) There was a commitment to challenging discrimination and inequality and there was a strong focus on community development. While Social Work has always played a role in “control” it felt that “care” was more to the forefront and was underpinned by recognition of the relationship between poverty, discrimination and disadvantage was closely linked to family’s ability to provide adequate care.

Social Work was seen as pioneering in this regard. Social Work Departments had Community Development sections. Welfare Rights Officers were regarded by the Director of Social Work as his “urban guerrilla’s” and managers were often prepared to give significant resources toward developing strategic approaches to reducing poverty, inequality and disadvantage.

At that time there was little in the way of regulation, professional standards or indeed activities that focussed on counting services or other forms of inspection. Perhaps there was some sense of intellectual superiority about this, some idea that because of the altruistic nature of services and their high mindedness those activities such as these were demeaning. Certainly there was a sense of trust and of belonging. Almost all of the time you felt supported and you felt that you were working toward a higher, more strategic set of goals.

I liked it, that approach had a profound effect on me. I was young and newly qualified at the time and there was a sense of direction, a sense of unity, of organising around a higher set of goals, a sense of leadership as opposed to management. Perhaps I was too young, too idealistic and the goals were too grand but it was a good place to be. An exciting space to be in.

Twenty years on and much has changed. And why should it not? I do not want this post to be some pean to a lost time. Uncritical of the past and acerbic about the present. Of course there were many issues “back then” High mindedness is one thing but when does this become indulgent? Public money should not be spent aiming high when people who use services were not getting the highest quality that they deserve. The approaches of the regional council happened because there was an environment there that allowed them to happen as that environment changes so does the space people operate within, that is the way of the world.

To say our space is different now would be an understatement. The Regional Council is long gone, replaced by smaller unitary authorities each with it’s own financial, moral and personal economy of scale. The voices of service users are much more prominent as are those of carers. Professional registration and regulation is much greater as is ongoing personal and professional development. Social Work has a developing professional identity and social workers are viewed much more readily as professionals.

The golden thread of New Labour’s personalization and individualization of services moved relentlessly onward (although approaches such as this were developing under the previous government)  and the current financial climate drives an agenda of “best value.” Services are subject to more thorough inspection and regulation and the concept of the 24/7 social worker has taken hold.

Social Work has, in my opinion, a greater recognition and a stronger professional identity. It has been elevated to a degree level qualification and the newer authorities offer greater opportunity for career development. Social Work seems now to have a more stable societal position; there is perhaps a greater recognition and understanding of the role of the social worker. As a profession it seems much better defined.

My concern is that a trade off has occurred, and I am not convinced of its benefit. Personalization and individualization offers a clearer definition of the role of the social worker, often described as some form of “broker.” Inherent in this are notions of professional assessments, and of advocacy. The emergence of the “carer” provides a third party that can provide comment on the professional role, a third party that has greater neutrality and a third party that has a sympathy from other members of society, many of whom do not have (or want) a caring role.

The regulation of services and of service providers presents a paradigm for value, the public can, if they want, see for themselves the quality of performance, they can decide for themselves if the service is good or bad. Increases in technology make the services more accessible, easier to reach. We have the growth of the expert (professional?) service user and an increased transparency around the activity of social workers.

All good? Well yes, but not an unreserved yes. Has those high minded, altruistic grand goals been sacrificed for this? Have we lost sight of the importance of service delivery being matched with a willingness to challenge the societal conditions that exacerbate it? Has the responsibility for this slid into the third sector, and in doing so became fragmented? I believe that the answer to this is yes, we do seem to have lost a vital perspective. People aren’t poor because of bad luck, or through their own fault. There are complex and indivualised reasons for this which I believe fall to Social Workers to understand and to attempt to challenge and / or resolve. I do not believe that social workers have a choice in this. I do not think it is good enough for social workers to focus on the individual and their needs at the expense of a wider perspective about how and why they got to where they are at in the first place.

The space changes but for me the challenges remain the same.  Poverty, discrimination, and inequalities exist and grown in a climate where there is a lack of response to the reasons for their existence. A wise old social worker once said that the drama of public service deserved centre stage and should never be played out in the wings.

7 thoughts on “Social Work’s professional space in Scotland

  1. Thanks for this. Being based in England, I sometimes present too narrow a focus so it’s good to have a Scottish perspective although fundamentally the issues are no different about carving out a place for social work. I see a greater future in advocacy roles and think that we, as a profession, need to be more resolute and political. I know it’s easier said than done..

  2. Pingback: Social Work’s professional space in Scotland « The Not So Big Society | Parents Rights Blog


    social workers welcome 01507 477 433 be a whistle blower

    We need you to Blog,Facebook,Twitter,Write to your news papers,tv,radioshow,Mp,Msp,president,More importantly go to your council building your goverment office your town centre and stop child abuse to do nothing is agreeing with the abusers.

    One Voice For The Kids and in association with the Against child Abuse Network, alongside many other global organisations who are against child abuse, are set to create the world’s largest Against Child Abuse Protest of its kind ever seen. Let me share a dream with you…does working in splendid isolation work for you and your organisation? Just stop and think for a moment. If you and your organisation works alone, in our experience, if you do what you have always done, you will get what you have always got. We are encouraging like minded organisations to join the Against Child Abuse Network as a point of contact between respective groups. To learn more about the network, click on the link or copy and paste the link below. Our vision is simple. Imagine a protest so large in numbers, all protesting on the same day around the world at as many of the world’s Government Offices as possible.

    Worldwide Lawful Rebellion.

    Who is up for it?

    It is time the world took a stand against these people in power. So, we are calling out to all like minded orgainsatios who are against child abuse, to join us and help in the planning of the worlds largest protest in history. It has never been done before. This is to take place on the same day. Although the idea of the “New Dawn ” has already been done, we can call it the “New Day”. We are looking for as many of the world’s organisations who are against child abuse to get behind this as we can.

    The against child abuse forum is ready to take your views on this worldwide protest.please follow this link and sign up. It has been restricted to invitation only to filter out any spam.

    If you are an organisation who is against child abuse, child stealing by the state, establishment cover-ups and child sex trafficking, we would very much like to hear from you. To participate or for further information regarding this protest, please log on to any of the following links shown below.

    So how can you help? Our vision is simple. The idea of the protest is to encourage people all over the world to take the day off and peacefully protest outside their own respective Government Buildings on the 6th March 2012 commencing at 5am. Simultaneous protests Facebook,Twitter Posts We Want This happening in as many time zones as we can get people to do. Around the world, children are being stolen from their parents using false evidence, perjury, threats and intimidation, false medical reports, including sectioning, fraud, and corruption in public authorities, police, courts and high-profile Government officials.

    Also check out about what is going on in Scotland and how the Scottish government are protecting child abusers and not the children.

    • Just browsing your website now.

      “We have been created by the need to fight widespread social care injustice and abuse of draconian state power. Children are being ripped from their parents simply because they are considered “unconventional” or even single.”

      Dear God, what utter bilge. I’ve worked on numerous child protection cases from a CAMHS perspective and I’ve NEVER come across a child being removed from parents simply for being “unconventional”.

      Taking a child into care is an utterly tortuous and complex process involving social services, the courts and usually multiple other agencies besides.

      Sorry, but on March 6th I’ll be going to work and doing my job.

      • read this then comment again some social workers are liars

        i noticed you worked for chams our social workers wont allow our 14 year old whos soiling shitting him self as he wants to go home been in care for 6 years go to childrens mental health service the courts believe social workers not the parents our kids are disabled we done nothing but bad diet and moving home wife a retard and husband too fat

        go to work on march 6th courts social workers are corrupt and paeds yes child abusers live with it its true

        i noticed you worked for chams our social workers wont allow our 14 year old whos soiling shitting him self as he wants to go home been in care for 6 years go to childrens mental health service the courts believe social workers not the parents our kids are disabled we done nothing but bad diet and moving home wife a retard and husband too fat

        enjoy your job

        my website isnt good but the issue is bigger

      • I think you may have lost me when you asked me to read a David Icke article.

        With all due respect, if social services have been refusing to let your kids go home for the past 6 years, I’m going to go out on a limb and suspect there may be a reason for that.

      • you have it yes stolen kids nothing else bye

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s